validating-and-verifying

Best Practices for Validating and Verifying CAE Simulations

Written by

Computer-Aided Engineering (CAE) has become essential for product design. But even the best software can mislead if not checked. That’s why validation and verification matter.

In this article, you’ll learn how to confirm the accuracy of CAE results. You’ll discover practical steps and tips for making your simulations more reliable. By the end, you’ll have a clear plan for verifying your CAE models.

Understanding the Importance of CAE Validation and Verification

Validation and verification are two distinct processes. Validation checks if the simulation reflects real-world performance. Verification checks if you built the model correctly.

Both steps protect you from costly errors. If you skip them, you risk design flaws and expensive redesigns. By carefully validating and verifying, you ensure dependable outcomes.

Building a Solid Foundation for CAE Accuracy

Before diving into simulations, you need a strong foundation. This includes choosing quality software and gathering reliable data. Preparation sets the stage for accurate results.

First, select the right CAE tools for your application. Different industries have specialized solutions. Next, collect accurate material properties and boundary conditions. Finally, confirm that your team understands the modeling process.

Best Practices for Validating and Verifying CAE Simulations

When it’s time to validate and verify, follow proven best practices. These steps help confirm that your simulation setup is correct.

1. Compare Against Analytical Solutions

  • Why it helps: Analytical solutions provide exact results for simple cases.
  • What to do: Solve a basic problem both analytically and in CAE. Compare outcomes for consistency.
  • Key point: If your simulation diverges from a known formula, fix the discrepancy first.

2. Benchmark Against Physical Tests

  • Why it helps: Experimental data offers real-world proof of how your system behaves.
  • What to do: Conduct controlled lab tests if possible. Match those results with your simulation.
  • Key point: Large differences between test and simulation often point to modeling or data errors.

3. Check Mesh Quality and Refinement

  • Why it helps: A poor mesh leads to inaccurate results.
  • What to do: Perform a mesh convergence study. Gradually refine your mesh and watch for stable results.
  • Key point: If results change drastically with each refinement, keep adjusting your mesh.

4. Refine Material Properties

  • Why it helps: Inaccurate material data skews your entire simulation.
  • What to do: Use reliable property databases or lab testing. Ensure you input values in the correct units.
  • Key point: Small variations in density or elasticity can produce big shifts in output.

5. Assess Boundary Conditions Carefully

  • Why it helps: Boundary conditions define how your model interacts with its environment.
  • What to do: Double-check your loads, restraints, and constraints. Ensure they match real-world scenarios.
  • Key point: Overly simplified conditions can distort your simulation results.

6. Document Assumptions Thoroughly

  • Why it helps: Hidden assumptions create confusion and errors.
  • What to do: Keep a clear record of each assumption. For instance, note friction or temperature constants.
  • Key point: Good documentation speeds future revisions and troubleshooting.

7. Leverage Sensitivity Studies

  • Why it helps: Sensitivity analyses reveal which inputs impact the results most.
  • What to do: Vary key parameters like material strengths. Track how outputs change.
  • Key point: Focus your validation efforts on high-impact factors to save time and effort.

Common Challenges and How to Overcome Them

Simulation doesn’t always go smoothly. Unexpected issues may arise. Here are some common challenges and tips to tackle them:

  • Computational Errors: High-fidelity models can lead to long run times or memory limits.
    • Solution: Simplify your geometry or use sub-modeling techniques.
  • Data Gaps: Sometimes, real-world data is scarce or inconsistent.
    • Solution: Use conservative assumptions or test parts of your model to fill gaps.
  • Software Limitations: Not all CAE packages handle every physics domain well.
    • Solution: Choose software suited to your project or use multiple tools for cross-checking.

By recognizing these pitfalls early, you can plan around them. This makes your CAE process smoother and more reliable.

Advanced Techniques for Enhanced Reliability in CAE

Once you master the basics, consider more advanced methods. These techniques boost confidence in your validated and verified simulations.

Multi-Physics Coupling

If your design involves heat, fluid flow, and structural loads together, multi-physics simulations are key. This approach captures the full picture. Verify each physics separately, then combine them carefully. Use incremental tests to check accuracy step by step.

Nonlinear Simulations

Many real-world problems involve nonlinear effects. Large deformations or complex material behaviors can’t be ignored. Validate each nonlinear feature (like plastic deformation or contact) with smaller test cases. Confirm your solver settings are correct.

Stochastic Methods

Real data often varies. In some cases, random factors impact performance. Monte Carlo simulations or probabilistic approaches can help. They show how variations in inputs affect your final output. Validate by comparing multiple runs against real distributions.

By layering these advanced methods, your CAE simulations become more robust. Yet always remember to build on a foundation of thorough validation and verification.

Conclusion

Validating and verifying CAE simulations is critical for accurate results. You’ve learned why these steps matter and how to follow best practices. By comparing against analytical and experimental data, refining your mesh, and documenting assumptions, you reduce errors.

Next, handle potential challenges with careful planning. Then, consider advanced techniques like multi-physics or stochastic methods for added accuracy. With these strategies, you’ll produce dependable CAE results that save time and money.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What’s the difference between validation and verification in CAE?

Validation checks if your model represents real-world behavior. Verification checks if your model is built correctly within the software. Both steps ensure accurate and reliable simulation outcomes.

2. How often should I validate CAE simulations with physical tests?

Whenever you have new designs or major changes, try to run at least one physical test. This gives you updated data and keeps your simulations aligned with actual conditions.

3. Why is mesh refinement so important for verifying CAE results?

A refined mesh usually produces more accurate results, especially for complex geometries. If your mesh is too coarse, you risk missing critical stress points or flow details.

4. Can I rely only on software default material properties?

It’s risky. Default properties might not match your specific materials. Always verify with your supplier’s data or conduct laboratory testing if possible.

5. How do I handle situations where real-world data is scarce?

Use conservative assumptions to ensure safety. Also, conduct partial tests or gather data from similar projects. This approach helps fill gaps while still maintaining realism.

Author Profile

Adithya Salgadu
Adithya SalgaduOnline Media & PR Strategist
Hello there! I'm Online Media & PR Strategist at NeticSpace | Passionate Journalist, Blogger, and SEO Specialist
SeekaApp Hosting